0
0 In civil litigation, particularly personal injury, wrongful death, and catastrophic loss cases, one of the most critical yet often overlooked early steps is the prompt and thorough investigation of insurance policy limits. Understanding how much insurance coverage is available can significantly influence litigation strategy, negotiations, client expectations, and case resolution.
Failing to investigate policy limits early can result in lost opportunities, ethical pitfalls, and adverse outcomes for clients. Conversely, an early and effective policy limits investigation can protect client interests, prevent unnecessary litigation, and ensure that settlements are fair and efficient.
Why Policy Limits Matter
Insurance policy limits define the maximum amount an insurer will pay under a liability policy. These limits form the outer boundary of potential recovery from the insurance company. Knowing these boundaries from the outset allows attorneys to:
Accurately assess the value of the case.
Strategically plan the litigation or settlement approach.
Avoid wasting resources on fruitless litigation.
Meet ethical obligations, including informed consent and honest communication with the client.
In high-damage cases with minimal coverage, an early policy limits investigation can lead to a policy limits demand, which may expedite settlement and protect the insured from excess exposure.
The Risk of Delay
Delaying the investigation of policy limits can lead to several problems:
Lost leverage: Early knowledge allows plaintiffs to make time-sensitive policy limits demands, which can create bad faith exposure for insurers.
Client dissatisfaction: Clients may pursue litigation for months or years only to find out that the potential recovery is limited.
Missed deadlines: In some jurisdictions, failure to promptly seek coverage information can limit discovery options later.
Ethical risks: Attorneys who fail to investigate policy limits may inadvertently mislead clients or fall short of providing competent representation.
Legal Tools for Policy Limit Discovery
Attorneys have several legal tools and approaches for discovering policy limits early in a case. These vary by jurisdiction, but common strategies include:
1. Voluntary Disclosure Letters
In many cases, the plaintiff’s attorney can send a formal letter requesting disclosure of all liability policies that may cover the claim. These letters typically request:
Names of all insurance carriers.
- Policy numbers.
- Limits of liability.
- Umbrella or excess coverage.
- Reservation of rights or coverage defenses.
Under many state laws, insurers have a duty to disclose this information upon request, especially if litigation is reasonably anticipated.
2. Statutory Obligations
Several states have statutory requirements that compel insurance companies or defendants to disclose liability coverage upon written request. For example:
California Insurance Code § 791.13 requires prompt disclosure in certain situations.
Florida Statutes § 627.4137 mandates insurers to disclose coverage information within 30 days of a written request.
New York Insurance Law § 3420(f) allows injured parties to request information about available insurance coverage.
Understanding your state’s statutes is essential to enforcing timely compliance.
3. Discovery Requests During Litigation
If informal methods fail, attorneys can seek policy information through discovery. Under most civil procedure rules, insurance coverage is considered discoverable because it is relevant to settlement and case evaluation.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(1)(A)(iv) specifically requires disclosure of insurance agreements that may satisfy part or all of a potential judgment.
Best Practices for Early Policy Limits Investigation
To protect your client’s interests, consider incorporating the following best practices into your early case strategy:
1. Begin Immediately
Initiate the investigation as soon as you are retained. If the case involves serious injuries or damages that clearly exceed personal assets, prioritize obtaining insurance information before investing heavily in litigation.
2. Use Precise Language
Draft your policy limits request letter carefully. Include:
Identification of your client and the date of loss.
A demand for certified copies of all liability insurance policies.
Requests for declarations pages, endorsements, and any excess coverage.
A request for the insured’s written consent to release the information, if needed.
A deadline for compliance and notice that failure to respond may result in further legal action.
3. Document All Communications
Maintain a detailed record of all correspondence with the insurer or opposing counsel. This can be critical if later alleging bad faith, concealment, or delay.
4. Confirm All Layers of Coverage
Primary insurance is only part of the picture. In high-value cases, excess or umbrella policies may be available. Ensure you ask for and receive details about all layers of coverage.
5. Advise the Client Accordingly
Once policy limits are known, communicate clearly with your client. Discuss:
The relationship between damages and available coverage.
Whether pursuing additional defendants is worthwhile.
The risks and benefits of making a policy limits demand.
This discussion is vital to managing expectations and securing informed consent.
6. Prepare a Policy Limits Demand When Appropriate
If damages far exceed available insurance, consider sending a clear, time-limited policy limits demand. These demands:
Must include a comprehensive summary of damages.
Should offer to settle within policy limits.
Should specify a deadline for acceptance.
Should avoid imposing unreasonable conditions.
When crafted properly, these demands can set the stage for bad faith claims if the insurer refuses to settle within limits.
What to Do When Insurers Stonewall
Unfortunately, not all insurers respond promptly or in good faith. If your requests are ignored:
Send a follow-up letter reiterating your request and citing relevant statutes or case law.
File a motion to compel in litigation, especially if discovery has commenced.
Consider a declaratory relief action if you suspect hidden coverage or bad faith conduct.
Notify regulatory agencies if the insurer is violating disclosure requirements under your state’s insurance code.
Timely and aggressive follow-up can prevent delays and protect your client’s rights.
Conclusion
Policy limits investigation is not just a procedural formality—it’s a strategic tool that can shape the entire direction of a case. By uncovering insurance coverage information early, attorneys can:
Maximize recovery opportunities.
Avoid unnecessary litigation expenses.
Protect clients from false hopes or bad faith conduct.
Satisfy ethical obligations of competence and communication.
In high-stakes litigation, information is power. A proactive approach to discovering policy limits can make the difference between a swift, favorable settlement and a long, costly battle. Attorneys who master this process are not just protecting their clients—they are advocating for justice in one of its most practical forms.
